more ads

Kamat's Potpourri

Kamat Memorial Volume .
Kamat's PotpourriNew Contents
About the Kamats
History of India
Women of India
Faces of India
Indian Mythologies
geographica indicaArts of India
Indian Music
Indian Culture
Indian Paintings
Dig Deep Browse by Tags
Site Map
Historical Timeline
Master Index
Research House of Pictures
Stamps of India
Picture Archive
Natives of India
Temples of India
Kamat Network
Blog Portal


Letter to Editor 

The following letter was written by Kamat to the Editor of Indian Express (the most circulated English language newspaper at the time in India) and was published in 1972 under the the title "A Scientists' Sad Story" It  makes a reference to a news item where a scientist, Dr. Shah, educated in U.S.A has committed suicide having failed to secure a job in India. 

A Scientists' Sad Story

Dr. K.L.Kamat 

The Editor 
The Indian Express 

Dear Sir, 

A lot of  controversy is going on the topic "Scientists in India" and you have published many letters on the subject. I have a doctorate from the State University of New York and wish to enlighten your readers with my story.

I was about to complete my studies when the UPSC sent a high official to persuade Indian scientists to return to India. I was interviewed in 1965 in New York for a high post and was informed that I would be taken up on a suitable job upon return to India. (Later on we understood that the official's main purpose was to visit his daughter studying in USA at the expense of the Government). Along with others I spurned lucrative jobs (then available) in the USA. 

Quote Begin
I did not commit suicide like Dr. Shah, but opted for a daily death for the sake of my family. 
Quote End

However, no employment was forthcoming in India upon return. After much correspondence CSIR appointed me as a Scientific Pool Officer and loaned my services to the Udaipur University in Rajasthan (my specialty was Forestry, and we all know how much forest  there is in Rajasthan). While I was with the Udaipur University, two teaching positions were vacant, and the authorities informed CSIR that I would be absorbed by the University. Hence the CSIR allowed me to continue in the post for thirty-three months. But the politicians inside and outside the University saw to it that these posts were not filled as long as I was with them, by postponing and canceling interviews and appointments.

While I was in the Pool, I applied for all the job posts suggested by the CSIR all over India, as also for others that were advertised in the newspapers. The advertisements are merely a facade put up to appoint their own nominees. The scientist prepares the job application in so many duplicates with all the certificates attached; then travels at his own cost and comes back. Once the time limit given for the interview was so short, that I had to travel by air from Jaipur to Bangalore. The interviews were very interesting, though they ultimately spelt misery for me. The interview committee pretends to judge my scientific abilities within fifteen minutes. The first four minutes are spent in narrating my educational qualifications; the next five minutes on answering questions which have no relevance to the post, and the remaining minutes are spent discussing the candidate's caste, and what would he do if he is not appointed, and such inane topics. In one interview in Delhi, I was asked if I was a Lingayat (a prominent community in South India)! The questioner was a Minister of Legislature, now elected on secular and anti-caste sentiments! Needless to say that such inquiries jarred my ears attuned to secular talk in the free society of Europe and America. In another interview I was offered an alternate post than what I had applied, but later the post was re-advertised on the insistence of a politician and was filled by a candidate from his state. It is not uncommon for the committee members to ask questions for which they themselves have no answers. In one case the Registrar was absent during the interview, and the remaining members of the selection team thereof were innocent of higher science. Finally, I could get only a temporary appointment to work in a PL 480 finance project. I had to resign from the post after twelve months of service as the project was about to be closed and new projects were not cleared by the ICAR.

I did not commit suicide like Dr. Shah, but opted for a daily death for the sake of my family. I am now self-employed after bidding good-bye to an academic career, scientific, scientific training and research aptitudes.

It is evident that the politicians have corrupted all the fountains of learning, research, and academic appointments. I have no doubt that undue influence was brought to bear on the appointing authorities by some interested politicians in Dr. Shah's case, and now they are after Dr. Swaminathan's blood; some scapegoat is required to mollify public opinion. But public memory is short. The report will be filled as usual and the beauracratic caravan will pass on.

Yours faithfully,


See Also:

 Kamat Memorial Volume
Kamat Memorial Volume

Kamat's Potpourri Remembering Kamat Memorial Volume

Research Database

© 1996-2017 Kamat's Potpourri. All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without prior permission. Standard disclaimers apply

Merchandise and Link Suggestions

Top of Page