more ads

Kamat's Potpourri


Subscribe to Site Feed
RSS Feed for AnthoBLOGy

Kamat's PotpourriNew Contents
About the Kamats
History of India
Women of India
Faces of India
Indian Mythologies
geographica indicaArts of India
Indian Music
Indian Culture
Indian Paintings
Dig Deep Browse by Tags
Site Map
Historical Timeline
Master Index
Research House of Pictures
Stamps of India
Picture Archive
Natives of India
Temples of India
Kamat Network
Blog Portal


Vikas Kamat
 Vikas Kamat is a programmer- entrepreneur living in Birmingham AL. This blog is a complex mix of Indian culture, life in southern USA, computer sciences, and sports. Opinions are his own.
 About - Bio - Contact

Friend Me on Facebook


Best of AnthoBLOGy

Unripe Revolution
Rooster's Dharma
Don't Know Jack
No Love for Condi
Blogger's Block
Father of  the Bride
TinTin's Diary - I
TinTin's Diary II
Hate Bollywood
Child Labor
M.F.Husain Guilty
Marathi & Konkani
Artist's Daughter
India's First IT Guru


Computing, Libraries, Tennis, India & other interests of Vikas Kamat


Review of Deepa Mehta's ''Water'' Durable Link to this BLOG
I saw Deepa Mehta's Water. This is an important movie, exposing the suffering of child-widows in India.

Fox Searchlight/

Widows Chuyia and Shakuntala ponder at Life

Set in circa 1938, it is about the suffering of Hindu widows, considered inauspicious and condemned to lead a life of severe penance (see: Miseries of a Widow). Graphic descriptions of an ashram and the daily activities are provided.

Unnecessary Controversy

The movie ran into controversies in India during its making because Hindu nationalists thought it represented Hindus and India in poor light. They burned the sets and caused violence against the crew. If the fundamentalists are so concerned about India's image, they should do something to eliminate the prejudice against widows in India. Protesting against this movie or Deepa Mehta is not worth it, because neither is "Water" a masterpiece, nor it is a documentary.

Lack of Authenticity

The movie, trying to depict organized cultural prejudice against widows lacks attention to detail, and hence is disappointing. The rave reviews the movie has received is solely due to the movie's sex appeal that the movie is about the "Status of Indian Women" made by an "Indian woman" (Mehta is based out of Toronto, but was born in India). It lacks the depth, drama, and honesty of similar movies made in India -- like the award winning Phaniyamma (1983).

Some quick visual anomalies I noticed are:

  • Rampant mixing of South (Dravida) and North Indian customs. Seventy years ago, the differences were much more pronounced.
  • Fake Hindi accents (especially by main characters Chuyia and Kalyani, they are pretty bad)
  • The movie is set in 1938, but they show Narayan hanging photograph of Gandhi taken in 1945.

The cinematography (by Giles Nuttgens) is quite stunning and provides a lesson in the use of lights and shades. I think the fundamentalists should have let Mehta do her thing, and we'd have been treated to spectacles of Varanasi akin to Kashi depicted by Satyajit Ray in Aparajito. Instead we get coconut trees on the banks of Ganga river (they had to film in Sri Lanka, I am told).

Actress Sarala as the young widow is very cute. Shakuntula (Seema Biswas)gives a very convincing performance.

I don't get the title of the movie. The title is absurd to the contents of the movie.


(Comments Disabled for Now. Sorry!)First Written: Sunday, August 27, 2006
Last Modified: 8/31/2006 8:01:03 AM
Tags: phaniyamma, widows

Browse More Entries


About Me:


Powered  NOT by Blogger or MovabaleType or WordPress, but by SimplyBlog, a software I wrote to create blogs.
See details of implementation or download SimplyBlog.



Dictionary Look up

Kamat PICTURESearch

Kamat Glossary Search

Kamat BLOGSearch

Amazon Search

Yahoo Mail Secure Site - Requires Login
GMail Secure Site - Requires Login
Hotmail Secure Site - Requires Login
BBC News
Yahoo! News
Kamat News
Indian Blogs
Blog Network
My Mailing List
Friends of Kamat
USTA TennisLink
What's New
What's Old
Adhika Prasangi
Frequent Visits
Lyons Computers
Dave Winer
Birmingham Local


This is how I surf the web. Turns out creating your own start page beats all portals, back-flipping, personalized corporate pages, and book-marking tools.
Kamat's Potpourri Vikas KamatBlog

© 1996-2014 Kamat's Potpourri. All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without prior permission. Standard disclaimers apply

Merchandise and Link Suggestions

    Top of Page